In These Times
Sharing topics and meaningful information to assist you in navigating the current climate
Merging Forward: Strategic Consolidation for Growth and Scale
Joe Watson
Founding Partner
Switch Innovation Lab
Nonprofits are facing a striking paradox. The needs for nonprofit services are growing, while the resources to meet those needs are shrinking. In this environment, succession planning and strategic partnerships — including mergers and acquisitions — have moved beyond hypothetical exercises and become essential leadership responsibilities.
The Case for Growth
Consolidation is a unique opportunity for mission advancement, and those organizations that approach it proactively position themselves for growth and scale. Consolidation can eliminate duplicative back-office costs, create stronger grant narratives, expand geographic reach, and attract talent that smaller organizations struggle to retain. A merged organization can make a more compelling case to major donors and foundations precisely because it demonstrates sustainability and ambition.
The Best Time to Start is Now
Leaders who initiate conversations early have the ability to shape what comes next. Lean into what makes your organization great and consider how this can be scaled. There is a significant difference between merging from a position of strength versus one of desperation. When an organization waits until reserves are depleted and staff are leaving, options become slim and the terms of any partnership become far less favorable.
Vision and Values First
The most common reason mergers fail is culture. Before any due diligence on balance sheets, ensure you are having honest conversations about mission alignment. Do both organizations ultimately serve the same community in compatible ways? Are theories of change compatible? How is impact measured?
A merger between two nonprofits with strong but divergent cultures will create internal conflict that negatively impacts the relationship before it begins. Change, especially at scale, can feel scary. When the timing is appropriate, ensure you are communicating with your internal teams to alleviate fears, and importantly, communicating the new opportunities available both individually and as an organization.
Preparing for the Conversation
Nonprofit leaders looking to explore growth opportunities can start by getting their own house in order: clear financials, documented processes, articulate mission statements, and a board aligned on long-term vision. Then begin quiet, informal conversations with peer organizations to build relationships and assess culture and mission fit.
Embrace the Moment
Nonprofit leaders are stewards of both operations and purpose. Consolidation and strategic partnerships are one way to ensure that the organization adapts and grows into the future.
Let's Talk About What's Possible
Whether you're exploring what strategic growth could look like for your organization or navigating the early stages of consolidation, we can help. We offer complimentary consultations to nonprofit leaders who are ready to think proactively about partnerships, mergers, and mission-driven growth. Contact Joe Watson at (440) 808-9843 or [email protected].
Elizabeth Voudouris, President and CEO of Business Volunteers Unlimited (BVU), has provided consulting, training and executive coaching services to hundreds of nonprofits and businesses since BVU's inception in 1993. Her work focuses on strengthening the governance and leadership of nonprofit organizations and facilitating strategic plans. She serves on the Board of the Cleveland Museum of Natural History, and the Governance Committee of the YWCA of Greater Cleveland. Previous board service includes the Akron Zoological Park. She has a Bachelor of Arts in History from Trinity College in Hartford, Connecticut and a Master of Arts in History from Kent State University.
This content is the opinion of the author. GAR Foundation draws on a range of perspectives from our regional community to share insights on nonprofit capacity building. We understand that organizations are unique and require different strategies for success.
Explore More
Share (or sign-up for) our newsletter!
Nonprofit leaders: we know your time is limited, and you may not always have a chance to dive into our newsletters. That’s why we’re asking for your help in expanding our reach within your organization. Please consider sharing this newsletter with your staff. They can also sign up to receive regular updates directly in their inbox by filling out this short form—it only takes a few seconds. Thank you!
Sign-Up Now
Browse our resources for nonprofits
We are dedicated to connecting grantees with relevant, affordable, diverse, and meaningful resources to help their organization's growth and development. Click on a link below to browse our list of trusted consultants, upcoming webinars/workshops, and helpful tools.
All resources shared are for informational purposes only. GAR Foundation bears no responsibility for the content found on external sites. Contact the external site for answers to questions regarding its content.